Skip to Main Content
HBS Home
  • About
  • Academic Programs
  • Alumni
  • Faculty & Research
  • Baker Library
  • Giving
  • Harvard Business Review
  • Initiatives
  • News
  • Recruit
  • Map / Directions
Working Knowledge
Business Research for Business Leaders
  • Browse All Articles
  • Popular Articles
  • Cold Call Podcast
  • Managing the Future of Work Podcast
  • About Us
  • Book
  • Leadership
  • Marketing
  • Finance
  • Management
  • Entrepreneurship
  • All Topics...
  • Topics
    • COVID-19
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Finance
    • Gender
    • Globalization
    • Leadership
    • Management
    • Negotiation
    • Social Enterprise
    • Strategy
  • Sections
    • Book
    • Podcasts
    • HBS Case
    • In Practice
    • Lessons from the Classroom
    • Op-Ed
    • Research & Ideas
    • Research Event
    • Sharpening Your Skills
    • What Do You Think?
    • Working Paper Summaries
  • Browse All
    Companies Can Expand Their Talent Pool by Giving Ex-Convicts a Second Chance
    Research & Ideas
    Companies Can Expand Their Talent Pool by Giving Ex-Convicts a Second Chance
    22 Apr 2022Research & Ideas

    Companies Can Expand Their Talent Pool by Giving Ex-Convicts a Second Chance

    by Jay Fitzgerald
    22 Apr 2022| by Jay Fitzgerald
    People with criminal convictions often have trouble finding work and face double-digit unemployment rates. Yet employers would be more willing to hire them under certain conditions, says research by Zoë Cullen.
    LinkedIn
    Email

    Employers looking to fill critical job vacancies may want to turn to a largely untapped pool of willing workers: people with criminal records.

    Employers are often wary of hiring workers with past convictions, leading to double-digit unemployment rates for formerly incarcerated people. That reluctance has hit Black Americans particularly hard since they have seen historically higher arrest rates, often fueled by racial discrimination, research shows.

    But it might be a good time to rethink those hiring practices and the biases underpinning them, suggests new research by Harvard Business School Assistant Professor Zoë Cullen. After all, the COVID-19 pandemic continues to create challenges for companies attempting to fill job openings as record numbers of people quit their jobs in search of new opportunities in a hot labor market.

    Cullen’s research shows employers are ready and willing to hire workers with a criminal history, especially if crime and safety insurance is available, or if the worker can provide past work performance reviews.

    The findings were included in a working paper, Increasing the Demand for Workers with a Criminal Record, which was recently published by the National Bureau of Economic Research. The paper was written by Cullen, Will Dobbie of Harvard Kennedy School, and Mitchell Hoffman of the University of Toronto.

    “There are a lot of companies willing to give workers with criminal pasts a second chance under the right conditions,” Cullen says. “Many of those conditions are being met now, or could be met with low-cost policies.”

    Do ‘Ban the Box’ laws backfire?

    In recent years, 35 states and 150 cities and counties have adopted so-called “Ban the Box” laws that restrict or delay employers from making criminal background checks on applicants seeking jobs, according to the paper. The goal of such laws is to boost hiring of those with past criminal records.

    But Cullen and colleagues questioned if such “Ban the Box” laws actually address the potential underlying reasons businesses conduct criminal background checks when making hires. They also wondered if restricting background checks might backfire, especially if employers resort to racial stereotypes to guess who might have a criminal record—and avoid hiring those people.

    So the researchers conducted field experiments involving the hiring decisions of nearly 1,000 businesses to test several approaches to increasing demand for workers with criminal records. The experiments asked hiring managers to make hiring decisions under different randomized “incentive-compatible” conditions.

    The researchers partnered with Wonolo, an on-demand job marketplace that connects businesses that need workers on a temporary or seasonal basis with hundreds of thousands of people searching for jobs. Wonolo was co-founded in 2014 by Yong Kim, a 2007 graduate of Harvard Business School.

    Reassurance and incentives open doors

    The researchers initially found that 39 percent of businesses were willing to work with those who had a criminal history without additional incentives or conditions. The level of demand was even higher for jobs that didn’t involve customer interactions or high-value inventory, and those that were difficult to fill.

    Then, the researchers started randomly offering extra hiring incentives to companies, including some that cost nothing to provide, and found that appetite for these workers increased substantially.

    In particular, providing objective performance information about workers with a criminal record overall increased demand by 13 percentage points, the study found. Offering crime and safety insurance covering damages up to $5,000 increased the level of demand for those with criminal records by 12 percentage points. Limiting the pool of job applicants to those who maintained a clean record for at least one year raised willingness to hire by 22 percentage points.

    Overall, with these assurances, more than 50 percent of companies were willing to hire workers with criminal histories.

    “They feel more comfortable about who they’re hiring,” Cullen says.

    The incentives might be cost effective, too. The team found that hiring incentives offered to businesses were less expensive than wage-subsidy programs backed by the federal government that were designed to address the same concern.

    “I was surprised by how effective modest, low-cost incentives can be when it comes to increasing the hiring of disadvantaged workers,” says Cullen.

    12,000 job offers

    Reassuring employers ultimately benefits society and business simultaneously, says Cullen. “It’s helping to close the racial gap in hiring in the US,” she says.

    Meanwhile, businesses gain by filling critical job vacancies, particularly during labor shortages. In all, the field experiments led to businesses offering 12,000 jobs to workers who applied for employment via Wonolo’s on-demand job marketplace, the study reports.

    “The bottom line is that there’s a much bigger pool of talent out there waiting to be tapped,” says Cullen.

    Kim of Wonolo says Cullen’s study validates what his company has observed in the marketplace: Businesses will hire workers with criminal records if they have the right incentives and information. “We believe anyone who has the will to work should be granted an opportunity to do so,” he says.

    Post A Comment
    In order to be published, comments must be on-topic and civil in tone, with no name calling or personal attacks. Your comment may be edited for clarity and length.
      Trending
        • 08 Sep 2022
        • Book

        Gen Xers and Millennials, It’s Time To Lead. Are You Ready?

        • 28 Mar 2023
        • Research & Ideas

        The FDA’s Speedy Drug Approvals Are Safe: A Win-Win for Patients and Pharma Innovation

        • 25 Jan 2022
        • Research & Ideas

        More Proof That Money Can Buy Happiness (or a Life with Less Stress)

        • 25 Feb 2019
        • Research & Ideas

        How Gender Stereotypes Kill a Woman’s Self-Confidence

        • 14 Mar 2023
        • In Practice

        What Does the Failure of Silicon Valley Bank Say About the State of Finance?

    Zoe B. Cullen
    Zoe B. Cullen
    Assistant Professor of Business Administration
    Contact
    Send an email
    → More Articles
    Find Related Articles
    • Employees
    • Recruitment
    • Employment

    Sign up for our weekly newsletter

    Interested in improving your business? Learn about fresh research and ideas from Harvard Business School faculty.
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
    ǁ
    Campus Map
    Harvard Business School Working Knowledge
    Baker Library | Bloomberg Center
    Soldiers Field
    Boston, MA 02163
    Email: Editor-in-Chief
    →Map & Directions
    →More Contact Information
    • Make a Gift
    • Site Map
    • Jobs
    • Harvard University
    • Trademarks
    • Policies
    • Accessibility
    • Digital Accessibility
    Copyright © President & Fellows of Harvard College